Labour Court Ruling: Non-tariff (außertariflich, AT) Pay Must Be Higher Than The Highest Collectively Agreed Wage
According to the IGBCE framework collective agreement in the chemical industry (Manteltarifvertrag,MTV Chemie), an AT employment relationship must fulfil the following criteria, among others:
› Exclusion from the collective agreement by individual contract
› the area of responsibility is more demanding than the highest pay scale employment group
› the pay and general working conditions as a whole exceed the minimum provisions of the collective agreement.
The collective agreement regulates the minimum conditions that must be met in order to establish a non-tariff employment relationship. This is precisely why collective agreements and their development are also important for non-tariff employees.
The specific minimum provisions for a non-tariff salary in the chemical industry resulting from the collective agreement and which non-tariff salary components have to be used for comparison were still unclear in parts.
An IGBCE member wanted to clarify this issue for himself and therefore brought his case before the labour court together with his union – with success!
Thanks to the free legal protection for trade union members, he was able to do this without any financial risk.
In the second instance, i.e. at the Rhineland-Palatinate Regional Labour Court, the chemical company from Ludwigshafen, which is bound by the collective agreement, had to pay a compensation payment on the basis of the collective agreement.
The judgement of the LAG is now final and binding:
Non-tariff employees have a „right to remuneration that maintains the pay gap […]“.
Simply translated: The highest collectively agreed pay group E 13 from the IGBCE collective agreement is the safety net that even AT employees can rely on in case of doubt. If the AT total remuneration falls below the annualized value of the benefits of the highest pay group of the above-mentioned collective agreements and the AT status is guaranteed in the individual contract, there is a claim to payment of the difference up to this value.
In its judgement of 27 January 2022, the LAG Rhineland-Palatinate (2 Sa 114/21) also confirmed the view of the IGBCE in case law. According to the LAG judgement, AT employees can only make a comparison with the collectively agreed pay group E 13 once all remuneration components for the respective year are known. This means that a comparison for the entire year can only be made with the bonus payment for the reference year. All components with remuneration character that were paid for the respective year must be taken into account on both sides.
The collective agreement does not regulate a minimum percentage difference requirement, but this can be specified in a company agreement. Particular attention should be paid to the contractual exclusion periods, which lead to the loss of entitlement to a compensation payment after a certain period of time.
Non-tariff pay must be higher than the highest collectively agreed wage – LAG Rhineland-Palatinate rules for the chemical industry
This does not yet mean that the proceedings will automatically apply to other AT employees, as the judgement initially applies only to the individual case. Nevertheless, the judgement points the way forward.
One thing is clear: joining the IGBCE pays off for AT employees, too.
Through its collective bargaining, the trade union ensures that the non-tariff salary is secured above E 13 and also actively enforces this for its members.
Deceptive packaging AT – chemical companies use intransparency to circumvent collective agreements
Following the decision on the collectively agreed minimum levels for non-tariff remuneration in the chemical industry, some colleagues will have a big question mark in their heads.
Many employees in the so-called AT pay systems in chemical companies are not AT employees within the meaning of the MTV Chemie. They are covered by the framework collective agreement for academically qualified employees (MTV AKAD) and are therefore, strictly speaking, employees covered by collective agreements. This is a good thing at first, because the collective agreement regulates entitlements such as 30 days‘ holiday, seniority-based time off (Altersfreizeit) or the 37.5-hour week. According to the employer‘s interpretation, however, E 13 is no longer applicable for these employees covered by collective agreements. Instead, the so-called minimum annual salary of the „Verband angestellter Akademiker und leitender Angestellter der chemischen Industrie e.V. (VAA)“ (Association of Salaried Academics and Executives in the Chemical Industry) is to be applied. These are far below E 13 and only apply from the second year of employment. For employees with a diploma or master‘s degree, the minimum annual salary for 2026 is €74,950, for employees with a doctorate €87,125. At first glance, this interpretation cannot be entirely dismissed. The works council cannot just circumvent this competition in the collective agreement landscape.
The majority of those affected are unaware of their collective bargaining status. Some chemical companies are extremely non-transparent in this regard and use the different collective bargaining regulations unilaterally in their favour. Those affected may be left out in the cold; under the current practice of many companies, they lose the security and benefits of collective bargaining without receiving adequate compensation in the form of higher pay.
To summarise: Many non-tariff pay systems in chemical companies cover two groups of employees with different collectively agreed minimum provisions – non-tariff employees under MTV Chemie with E 13 from the IGBCE collective agreement as the lower limit and collectively agreed employees under MTV AKAD with the minimum annual salary of the VAA as the lower limit. Companies are often intransparent when making this distinction.
Assuming that this practice is in line with collective agreements (which has simply not yet been clarified): Companies cannot arbitrarily decide on the application of collective agreements.
According to current case law, AT employees enjoy the protection described above for minimum remuneration above E13.
In the view of the IGBCE, employees covered by the MTV AKAD are to be grouped into the collectively agreed pay system; at least until they fulfil the conditions for a genuine AT employment relationship. Until then, they are entitled to collectively agreed benefits such as annual benefits (Christmas bonus), holiday pay or the future allowance.
It is therefore advisable to seek advice from the IGBCE on your status under the collective agreement.
The IGBCE has already set itself the goal and is working on addressing the ambiguities in this area through collective agreements.
Most importantly, this requires the support of the employees concerned through active union membership as collective bargaining policy is ultimately determined by the members themselves.
You can find your local IGBCE district here: Finde Ansprechpartner aus deinem IG-BCE-Bezirk
You can join here: Become a member